image

Fourth Wall

Fourth Wall

A literary term often utilized in theater to describe the imaginary barrier between the actors and audience, separating real world and fantasy. Breaking the fourth wall is observed sometimes in literature, where a character directly addresses the reader.

Name:
Fourth Wall
Aliases:
Start year:
1936
First issue:
Funny Pages (1936) #2 Vol.1 #2
cover

Overview

Some characters have been known to 'break the fourth wall' by speaking to, or about, the audience. Not only do they talk to the reader, but they (usually) know that they are fictional creations in a story. On occasion, this may be a vehicle for dramatic irony. Deadpool, the most well known example of this phenomenon, has been known to refer to his own history in issue format, lean on the panel borders, and see or touch his thought boxes and word balloons.

The fourth wall can also be reinforced by a character saying that, i.e., 'this isn't a movie, you know'.

Characters

Characters that have broken the Fourth Wall

(Note: Characters may have broken the 4th wall at one point in time, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they currently retain the knowledge of the world beyond the comic they are in)

  • Alex Luthor
  • Ambush Bug
  • Animal Man
  • AO Major
  • Bat-Mite
  • Black Hand
  • Bomb Queen
  • Canis
  • Cerebus
  • Deadpool
  • Demon
  • Fig Keele
  • Forbush Man
  • Gabreality
  • Gary, the Pathetic Fallacy
  • Go-Go Fiasco
  • Grifter
  • The Intern
  • Jack Horner
  • Jamie Braddock
  • John Constantine
  • John Lynch
  • The Joker
  • Jon Johnson
  • Lobo
  • Loki
  • Mr. Mxyzptlk
  • Mr. Revise
  • Phantom Stranger
  • Pinkie Pie
  • Promethea
  • Purple Man
  • Quantum & Woody
  • She-Hulk
  • Squirrel Girl
  • Starman
  • Superboy Prime
  • Suzie Dickson
  • T-Ray
  • The Killer
  • Uatu the Watcher
  • Zatanna

Creators

Note: This list does not include creators who are in (auto)biographical comics as these stories are about the creators and set in the real world, not in a fictional one. Also, homages to creators or "easter egg" appearances do not count, the characters have to explicitly make clear they are breaking the fourth wall.

Some writers break the fourth wall by inserting themselves into the story, wherein their character admits to writing the story they are appearing in:

  • Alan Moore as Alan Moore: Wrote himself into Promethea when "the world was ending" and our realities were converging, he is seen writing the script for the page he appears on.
  • Ben Templesmith as Ben Templesmith: He claims to be the biographer for Wormwood, Wormwood writes him off as some loon but Templesmith gets irate claiming he's had Eisner nominations three years in a row now, yeah, whatever.
  • Brian K. Vaughan as Brian K. Vaughan: Written into Ex Machina as the writer of the comic that will follow the life of Mayor Hundred, shares some of his own personal stories and feelings about New York City and 9/11. Y: The Last Man is also referenced where he clears up that the Daughters of the Amazon are asexual not lesbians. Ironically, he criticizes the use of inserting oneself into the story, mentioning Grant Morrison and saying that it's too "meta" and takes him out of the story.
  • Grant Morrison as The Writer: Perhaps the most well-known example, Grant Morrison inserted himself into the end of his Animal Man run (which was already full of instances where the Fourth Wall was broken) and he explains everything to Animal Man, why he killed his family, what his views are, etc. He mentions that he's also writing Doom Patrol and in the end "restores" everything to the status quo.
  • J.H. Williams III as J.H. Williams III: Written into Promethea, alongside Alan Moore (see above); is seen drawing the two-page spread he appears in.
  • Jonathan Ames as Jonathan A.: Protagonist of The Alcoholic. Although this is something of a unique situation, being that the comic is semi-autobiographical, the comic is not meant to be taken as a factual detailing of the writer's life and has fiction inserted, however, the character does talk directly to the reader at points. Although he is more of a character then a creator writing himself into a comic, he is placed in this list due to the fact that his name and life are based on his creator.
  • Roy Thomas and his wife Jeanie are introduced at a Halloween Party to the other guests in The Avengers #83, written by Thomas. They are dressed as Spider-Man and Mrs. Fantastic. Jeanie Thomas is asking one of the Avengers which of them Mrs. Peel is.
  • Peter Milligan as Miles Laimling: "Laimling" being an anagram of "Milligan". He is originally just some guy writing "The Great American Novel" in Hotel Shade and stealing the identities of Shade, Lenny and Kathy as he writes them. Eventually he breaks the Fourth Wall entirely when he says he's going to write their adventures as a comic and looks at the reader.
  • Tony Harris as Tony Harris: Appeared with Brian K. Vaughan (see above), he is portrayed as the "cooler" of the two and brings his art portfolio to show off to Mayor Hundred's staff. While Vaughan talks with Hundred, Harris hangs out with January and other staff and draws Bradbury in a "badass-style" pose.

Other creators have also appeared in comics, although were inserted by someone else, rather then doing it themselves:

  • Karen Berger as Karen Berger: Inserted into House of Mystery #292 (her first book edited at DC) as the editor to replace Len Wein (see below). Cain seems to warm to her quickly.
  • Len Wein as Len Wein: Apparently Cain doesn't think he's a very good editor.

Fifth Wall

When characters break the "Fifth Wall," it shows they have knowledge of other fictional characters from another, unrelated actuality.

Examples

in The Amazing Spider-Man #123, after being hit through a window by Spider-Man, Luke Cage says "I dig, Spider-Man ... but here's something you don't! Some dudes have to do this number for a livin' -- we ain't all rich playboys like Bruce Wayne." Note that Luke Cage should probably not know of Bruce Wayne, and vice versa.

In Superman #50, Mr. Mxyzptlk makes several statements hinting that he is also the Impossible Man from Marvel Comics and has knowledge of the Fantastic Four, such as "Having fun with my new fantastic friends," "back to my four new friends," It's blubbering time," and "Sometimes it's just impossible to remember what I look like from world to world."

Recap Pages

Some comics have recap pages before the actual story in which characters from that issue (or sometimes the previous one) show up and talk to the reader, breaking the Fourth Wall. These instances are generally isolated and after the recap page, the characters no longer have the ability to break the Fourth Wall. For examples of this, check out the Cable/Deadpool and Irredeemable Antman series.

Likewise in pages outside of the story, usually at the back of the comic in distinctly separate areas, characters will often address the reader for promotional purposes or for humorous effect.

Issues

August 1939

January 1942

October 1942

November 1942

December 1942

January 1944

February 1947

February 1948

October 1948

August 1950

June 1958

July 1958

December 1960

January 1961

May 1961

August 1961

August 1962

February 1963

April 1963

May 1964

October 1965

February 1966

August 1966

August 1967

December 1967

May 1968

March 1969

Volumes

1937

1938

1939

1940

1941

1942

1954

1955

1956

1958

1959

1960

1961

1963

1968

1969

1975

1978

1980

1984