When a food fight breaks out in Arkham Asylum, more than meals gets splattered. To protect himself, White attempts to gain the favor and protection of a rather well known villain: Two-Face. But how do you trust a guy whose very name implies anything but?

Life in Arkham Asylum continues to be hell for Warren White, and Jeremiah Arkham is a lot less sympathetic than Anne Carver was, partly due to his own pension plans being scuppered by White's crimes. Dr Arkham asks lifer Humpty Dumpty for help when a mirror is smashed - Dumpty can put anything back together. Soon, after one too many attack by his fellow inmates, White forms an alliance with Two-Face, becoming his "coin boy", but this does not prove advantageous when Death Rattle threatens his life and Two-Face refuses to help due to the result of a coin toss. Humpty Dumpty, however, has worked out Death Rattle's plans and arranges for White to move cells to share with him in order to save his life.