Jack Knight returns to the freak show to free the alien Starman one way or another. But will both Starmen be able to cope with the price of freedom? Plus, a figure from Opal City's past begins to awaken, and a mysterious demon poster returns with its equally mysterious owner.

While bargain-hunting with farmers in Turk County, Jack Knight comes upon a circus, operated by a man named Bliss, and home for a number of freaks including a Cosmic Geek. The other freaks enlist him to champion their escape from Bliss and his assistant Crusher.